Showing posts with label crisis. Show all posts
Showing posts with label crisis. Show all posts

Thursday, August 28, 2008

Avoid absolute statements in a crisis

Prime Minister Stephen Harper says that his government still plans to hand more responsibility for food inspections to the industry, “to change the system to make sure that we have greater responsibility on those who ultimately market the product." He will regret sticking to his guns.

The advice I give clients in crisis includes a warning against making absolute statements. “There’s no possible way that listeria contaminated product could come from our processing plant.” In the early stages of a developing crisis, put emphasis on collecting evidence and facts. Information is incomplete in the early phases of a surprise event. It is important to be able to confront opinion with facts. Making a statement that you eventually have to repudiate can destroy credibility.

In this case, the Prime Minister should have left his options open. Regardless of his faith in the policy of devolving responsibility for product quality to industry as “right”, he has painted himself into a corner. When the federal inspection system at the plant is found to have been inadequate in the perception of the Canadian public, being “right” will be dead wrong.

Addressing emotions trumps logic

Maple Leaf Foods and Michael McCain have earned respect and a measure of praise for the response to the listeria crisis. That may change.

A class-action lawsuit against Maple Leaf Foods in the wake of the listeria crisis that has claimed six Canadian lives to date, accuses the company of telling its commercial partners about the contamination four days before warning the public. The suit alleges the company was aware of the potential toxicity of several of its food products four days prior to informing consumers but chose only to inform distributors, placing consumers at risk. During this interim period hundreds of Canadians likely consumed the suspect food products and many may have fallen ill.

The assertion has not been proven and it is likely that the company and the Canadian Food Inspection Agency have an explanation that is reasonable to them. The test will be whether their response to the allegation – not yet addressed by either the company or the CFIA – will be acceptable to Canadians processing information with emotion more than logic.